Thursday, August 9, 2007

About SIP walls and a residential flat roof, logic behind these alternative building methods

As our design is coming together under our structural engineer, Green Earth Engineering, I thought I should explain how and why we chose SIP walls and a residential "flat" roof design. They are
mostly because of cost-effective and energy efficient reasons, and I'll explain why in layman's terms.

First, SIPs are a composite building material. They consist of a sandwich of two layers of structural board with an insulating layer of foam in between. The board is usually Oriented Strand Board (OSB) and the foam either expanded polystyrene foam(EPS), extruded polystyrene foam (XPS) or polyurethane foam .


They are not commonly used in the building industry due to knowledge or resistance to trying new methods, which is very unfortunate, because they are superior to conventional stick framing and pay themselves back in cost due to energy savings.


So here's a breakdown of why we chose SIPs pulled from my architect's website:

Benefits for homeowners
* Extremely strong structure. There is considerable evidence that homes with SIP wall and ceiling panels have survived natural disasters like hurricanes, tornadoes, straight-line winds and earthquakes better than traditional stick-framed homes right next door.
* Lower energy bills. Discounting the "human factor"-thermostat settings and so forth-a number of side-by-side tests show that between 15% and 40% less energy should be needed to heat and cool a home with SIP wall and ceiling panels. In tests by Oak Ridge National Laboratory, SIP walls outperform fiberglass walls by over 50%.
* Improved comfort. Thanks to extra R-values and tight construction, the wall and ceiling surfaces in a SIP home will stay warmer than in stick-framed homes. The warmer those surfaces are, the more comfortable the home is.
* "Freeze proof." What happens if the power goes down? During the late 1990s, several New England SIP homes survived over a week without power or a wood stove and never came close to freezing.
* Indoor Air Quality. While there is no guarantee here, most homes built with SIPs are tight enough that builders can't ignore upgrading mechanical ventilation compared to that found in a standard home. In many studies in North American housing, the best indoor air quality is found in homes that are tight and equipped with upgraded mechanical ventilation.
* Green building product. On a life-cycle basis, a more energy-efficient house built with SIPs will be less damaging to the environment, in terms of overall resource consumption. Much less dimensional lumber is used in a SIP home than in a traditional framed structure.
* Interactive systems benefits: For example, a more energy-efficient home may cost slightly more to build but in turn can be heated and cooled with smaller equipment that costs less to install.

Benefits for construction
* Speed of construction. You can order the panels with all pre-cutting performed in a factory. They show up on the jobsite all pre-numbered, ready for assembly.
* Fewer framers. A crew can consist of one lead framer assisted by minimally skilled helpers.
* Shell installation option. If you're having a tough time locating skilled carpenters, a growing number of manufacturers have regular crews who will install a shell on your foundation for you to finish.
* Rigid frame. It's easy bracing SIP walls. In fact, once you have two corner panels up, you can lean a ladder against the panels when needed.
* Less jobsite waste. If you've ordered a set of panels with all rough openings for windows and doors pre-cut at the factory, the only true waste you'll have is taking a few cases of empty tubes of adhesive caulk containers to the dump.
* Less theft. While 2x4s and 2x6s are prone to "walking off" unsecured job sites, panels are too specific to the site's building system to be worth hauling off somewhere else.
* Cost competitive. While most builders say they pay a little more for SIPs than for the comparable framing and insulation package in a stick-built home, as a group they believe the benefits are worth the costs. The amount extra they pay varies; while a few say it costs them an extra $1 per square foot of finished floor area, the amount may be higher when roof panels are used. However, when roof panels enclose extra living space in a loft, the price per square foot is surprisingly competitive. If at the design stage you optimize a structure to use panels, the most experienced SIP builders then say a house framed with SIPs should cost about the same as a house framed with comparably sized dimensional lumber, and maybe even a little less.
* Easier to hang drywall. There is solid backing for all drywall against exterior walls, which means there is less cutting, faster attachment and less waste material.
* Fewer framing callbacks. Wall panels go in plumb, square and straight. Once in place, a SIP won't warp, twist or check.

As for our "flat" roof design, our architect advised us that a good way to SAVE MONEY is to get a commercial grade "flat" roof because you don't have to pay for those beautiful Spanish ceramic tiles found on Spanish/Mediterranean style homes, which can get extremely expensive. Besides that, the flat roof goes wonderfully along with our design aesthetic, it being modern and clean-lined. Now, many modern homes use metal roofs with overhangs, which are equally as nice, but we chose this design for cost reasons, having to be "cheap" but not compromise a good quality structure.

The way our roof will be designed is it will first be a SIP panel, then styrofoam wedges to give the roof a 1 to 12 pitch for rainwater drainage, then a thin membrane lining. There will be a parapet wall (wall that goes higher than the roof line) as shown below:


The reasoning behind the parapet wall is to both protect and "cover" all that is ugly on top of the roof. We will also prepare our roof to be solar panel ready.

As you can see in this design, we will not have a truss or attic space under the ceiling as the interior will soar all the way up to the SIP panel, creating a spacious looking living room with extremely high ceilings! High ceilings make any room look bigger, which is the effect we are after. The duct work from our HVAC will be in the floor of the 2nd story, thereby not needing an attic or truss at the ceiling.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

SIPs are finally being accepted in the mainstream as a practical building method. As their frequency of use continues to increase, their cost will only become more competitive.

www.sandwichpanels.org

Anonymous said...

I was talking to a Buildings Materials Professor once (I'm a Mech. Engr) and his reservations about SIPS (the OSB/foam sandwich kind). He was worried that if there was ever delamination between the OSB and foam you would loose structural integrity. He preferred a panel where metal studs were molded INTO the foam (this also makes the panels lighter and electrical and plumbing work faster).. panels can be 4' wide and up to 12' high... (thermasteelcorp.com is just one of the suppliers)

Jan & Myleen said...

Delamination is a very real concern, but according to some EPS SIPs suppliers, the only instance of delamination that they know of (and you would have to do more research to verify) happened in Alaska. It occured due to the very extreme cold temperatures that affected the glue and because they didn't caulk that building correctly, it delaminated. Since we are building in Texas, and that type of cold extreme doesn't occur here, the likelihood is slim to none. But thanks for the tip, and I will look into it more. I want to hear all sides to the debate.

pringstrom said...

Two things to consider for those worried about delamination of the OSB: 1) Use Grailcoat stucco applied directly to the OSB which will waterproof the exterior 2) Replace the OSB with fiber cement. www.thermasave.us

Jan & Myleen said...

Hey pringstrom! Thanks for coming by! We have thought about using Grailcoat stucco for another kind of application but have never thought about this. Is this what you did to your house? I'll look into the Thermasave.

Anonymous said...

The Grailcoat Company LLC is no longer in business they filed to dissolution of the company in June of 2007 you can look it up at www.sunbiz.org and formed a new company D J Grail Company LLC.
They filed disolution saying expensed exceeded revenues. They have sold alot of product with a 20 year warranty under the Grailcoat Company LLC and now do not have to cover any of it. It is a shame that companies disolve and then form a new company to take more money from customers and not have to held liable. I would be very leary of buying anything from the new company they probably will do the same thing. They take your money upfront for orders and I know of a someone waiting a month later that still has not got product they paid for. How can companies get away with this it just is not right but how can you sue a company that has nothing to take.

public sex positions said...

I did not know how your was your house made
thank for the information

Robin said...

Kids double bedding - A wonderful collection of baby bedding for cots and cot beds, wall borders stickers murals wallpapers and wall art, childrens duvet covers and curtains for boys and girls dream bed rooms.
designer dining room furniture - Mustard Monkey offers a huge range of Luxury & Designer Bedroom, Living Room & Dining Room Furniture. We also promote kitchen appliances and bathroom accessories.
cheap rugs - Add a beautiful rug to a room to warm a cold space or update a traditional look. We have a massive choice of different sizes and colours.

Polyurethane foam roofing said...

Nice blog. I appreciate your effort and thankful to you for posting this.

LEED Construction Austin said...

Burt-watts buildings to unquie commercial iteriors, This seems to be a great site which offers LEED Construction Austin, Green Construction Austin, LEED and Green Construction Austin etc and i would surely like to try their service...i had been relying on Commercial Construction Austin earlier and they too offered good stuff.

whit said...

Burt-watts buildings to unquie commercial iteriors, This seems to be a great site which offers LEED Construction Austin, Green Construction Austin, LEED and Green Construction Austin etc and i would surely like to try their service...i had been relying on Commercial Construction Austin earlier and they too offered good stuff.

whitejohn said...

We are Cool Earth Contracting & Coating.This seems to be a great site which offers Reflective Paint Austin, Commercial roof, Commercial roofing, Cool roof etc. and i would surely like to try their service...i had been relying on Roofing commercial earlier and they too offered good stuff. You will be glad you decided to work with them.

anil kumar said...


Thanks for sharing your interested & knowledgeable points there are some

relevant beneficial points lucknow property are affordable and there are

many property here for your investment & futureble here are many type

property for detail view it.
lucknow property
bbd green city lucknow
property in lucknow
ansal golf vista lucknow
rg euphoria lucknow

The Geeks said...

hi..Im college student, thanks for sharing :)

david james said...

This is a great article, Thanks for giving me this information. Keep posting.
Flat roofing systems company

Yitac Pte Ltd said...

Information is pretty good and impressed me a lot. This article is quite in-depth and gives a good overview of the topic.
Polyisocyanurate Rigid Board